Skip to main content

An Open Letter To Confused Traditional Catholics

 +
JMJ

It seems that the Crisis of the Catholic Church has cast a veil of confusion over all Catholics, as the ones in authority, that they should have been able to trust, have one by one betrayed this trust. Naturally, over 50+ years, this confusion has spread over the world as various individuals and groups vie for the attention of the masses.

Anyone who looks at various 'social media' apps will find people electronically screaming through your computer / cell phone / tablet to grab your attention, get a rise out of you, crank up your emotions and then keep them there.  

In this age of instant information gratification, it is easy to get lost in the noise. Just like in the image below, you can't see the real signal and those high peaks are just larger bursts of noise that spike up from the 'crowd' once in a while.There's no hidden message in the noise, it's just noise.  There's no way to distinguish the signal from the noise, the important from the unimportant.


As Traditional Catholics we have decades of examples of people following the noise. 

The Sedevacantists have been saying the decades that the See of Peter is vacant. Except, that can't be since the First Vatican Council declared that there would be popes until the end of the world.  But we really want an excuse to chuck the hierarchy - especially with Pope Francis.  It would be nice, but to do so it is necessary to deny a few Dogma's of the Catholic Church. In other words, you have to become a protestant, picking and choosing what to believe and what to creatively re-imagine.

Then we have the "Resistance", new (2012+) and old (1982+) who have been  screaming from YouTube videos of a sell-out by the SSPX.  Only, here we are a decade or in some cases 5 decades later and the SSPX is still doing what it does - adhering to the Teachings of the Catholic Church. Yet, in the absence of a real sell-out the resistance desperately looks for anything that they can point to and scream, "There look at that, it's a sell-out." The "Resistors" I know have made incredibly bad decisions. One in particular, started by hosting the "resistance" in St. Mary's, became disillusioned, shifted to another branch of "Resistors", then to the Sedevacantists, then another, and another - until ending up as home aloners. The last I heard they believe that they are part of the last faithful remnant of the Church. How is that Father providing for the spiritual welfare of his children?

Then you have the whining about COVID-19, masks, and conspiracy theories. 'nuff said on that mole hill.

On top of this we have the noise about vaccines, whether you can morally be vaccinated, the dangers of vaccinations, the dangers of not being vaccinated, whether the world power created the vaccine etc, etc, etc.  

One recent 'open letter' calls on Traditional Catholics (link) to follow the modern Catholics by setting aside the principles of St.Thomas Aquinas. Seriously, how can a Traditional Catholic write something like that and still think they're on the right path?  

In addition, people have said to me, "You know that your position on the vaccines runs against the majority of the Traditional Catholics". That is a really bad argument since, I could easy say, well the Traditional Catholics are a microscopic percentage of the Catholic Church and following that logic, we should accept the Novus Ordo Missae and Vatican Duo.  

With all these shiny things, Traditional Catholics are just being led by the laser pointer to the next 'BIG' thing. Whatever that may be.


This letter is my call to Traditional Catholics EVERYWHERE to step back from the madness, take a breath and start to think about what is really important. 

We are here to "Know, Love and Serve God in this life, so we can be happy with Him in the next"! For those who have forgotten, to be happy with Our Lord in the next life, we have to 'save our souls' first, then those for whom we are responsible.  

That means we need to do our duty of state and in this crisis it is harder, but not impossible.

We need to take care of our own duties before we help someone else.  That is their business, only when our own 'house' is in order can we move outwards.  For some it seems that the various crises are an excuse to step away from their duties. That is a big mistake.  If you don't do your duty, then you are in a death spiral.

Our duty of state is a filter that helps us to hear the signal, it tells us what we must do to be saved. It is the razors edge we must use to cut out the noise from our lives and realize what is important.

So, to all Traditional Catholics, understand your duty, fulfill it and stop messing around in other people's business. That's their problem, don't make it yours. 

Unless you are a politician, then you have an even bigger duty and should ask for prayers because that road is treacherous even for those with the burden to walk it.

Profit from this Advent, to understand your duty to God, country and family.

P^3


P.S. The Advent Series started on December 1st.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What is Tradition?

 + JMJ What Is Tradition? The basic premise, from my perspective, is that what was taught before cannot be contradicted by the 'present' magisterium, only deepened and expanded upon. I recall the Roman theologians called the SSPX protestants while the SSPX called them modernists.  I believe this was all surrounding the concept of Traditon. SSPX's Understanding of Tradition One accusation made against the SSPX is that they don't have a correct understanding of 'Tradition'.  This is how the SSPX understands Tradition: I finally profess that Tradition is not a dead memory, but the living transmission of the doctrine received from the Apostles. It remains living, in distinction to Revelation, which is closed. It is so both in the activity of the Magisterium of the Teaching Church and in the profession of Faith of the Church Taught, of which the sentire cum Ecclesia is the result of the teaching of the Magisterium. Tradition may be called ‘living’, not in the sense t...

SSPX.ca: What is the position of the SSPX on Vatican II???

 + JMJ With all the mis-information about the SSPX rejecting the Second Vatican Council, I thought it would be useful to publish an article that focuses on the real issues that the SSPX has identified. Update: Why Did the SSPX Consecrate Bishops? ( Neither Schismatic, Nor Disobedient link ) In the linked document the SSPX outlined the key motivation and core issues with Vatican II and the post-conciliar magisterium (see above link for full document): 4. The Society Acted Precisely Because of the State of Necessity in Which the Faith Finds Itself  In the present situation of the Church, if the Society of Saint Pius X had not carried out the consecrations of July 1st, it would have found itself facing an inevitable alternative: either to disappear gradually, or to accept, at least in fact, the new liturgy as well as the false doctrines of Vatican II and the post-council. Without the consecrations of July 1st, the Fraternity would have found itself, in a few years, without bishop...

Thoughts on: Finding Common Ground Between Rome and the SSPX

 + JMJ In the ramp up to the consecrations the noise floor in the intergnat grew to a constant din.  This was one of the few the peeped its signal over the noise. https://crisismagazine.com/opinion/finding-common-ground-between-rome-and-the-sspx The key issue is contained in this paragraph: In the lead-up to the planned July 1, 2026, episcopal consecrations,  the SSPX rejected Rome’s offer  of doctrinal dialogue on the grounds that “we both know in advance that we cannot agree doctrinally, particularly regarding the fundamental orientations adopted since the Second Vatican Council.” Fr. Pagliarani also said that his previous attempt at dialogue in 2019 was shut down by Rome because of an assumed irreconcilability. It seems that, from the Society’s perspective, and perhaps from Rome’s too, their positions are incompatible. If memory serves, Rome killed any opportunity for an open discussion by stating that Vatican II was not up for debate. So it was a still-birth and ...

Thoughts on the Thoughts of a former SSPX priest

 + JMJ Well Gary Campbell, former SSPX Priest and now laicised has posted a new article on WherePeterIs. https://wherepeteris.com/thoughts-of-a-former-sspx-priest-on-the-july-1-consecrations/ These words stuck out: Heck, they have built a five-star hotel, wine bar, and Walmart on the opposite bank of the Rubicon! They are not in danger of entering a state of schism, for they are  already  in a state of schism. I believe he doth protest too much. All the actual facts indicate that the SSPX was not in a state of schism before July 1st and an examination of the decree of excommunication highlights the either ineptitude of those in charge or a desire to leave the barn door open. The chasm between an act of disobedience and act of schism remains just what is has always been - an inconvenient barrier that person(s) in Rome seek to bridge but appear incapable of succeeding. The SSPX re-stated that they recognize the Pope as the Vicar of Christ and feel obliged by conscience...

The News is an Addiction ...

 + JMJ People seem to be mesmerised by train wrecks.   They just can't turn away as the disaster creeps forward along train tracks towards the crossing where a car, truck, bus, trailer awaits its destruction. Trads have been watching the train wreck that is this crisis of the Catholic Church for decades. The trade war between the Canada and the US has reminded me that the news is addictive.   The first time I was addicted what from 2009 to  2014 when I was closely following the Rome / SSPX discussions.  I was at work watching a live-stream as Bishop Fellay disappeared into the Vatican. The lead-up to this moment had been intense as the 'resistance' got freaked out and the cultural cracks between doctrine and conspiracy theory widened. In the decade since then other things have emerged, wars, rumours of wars, conspiracies, celebrity Catholics etc. Now we have a new addiction and its name is Trump. Lately, no matter how much I try, I find myself wonderin...