+
JMJ
In reading the chatGPT outputs, I noticed that, while citing the Father’s and earlier writings of the Church, earlier Church Councils etc are absent.
So I created a new prompt to investigate what the LLM (i.e. chatGPT) would produce.
Prompt
Looking at the pre 1960 documents of the Catholic Church, which ones included the care and love of the poor?
Result
That’s an excellent question — and a deeply revealing one. Long before 1960, the Catholic Church had already developed a strong tradition of teaching on the care and love of the poor, rooted in Scripture, the Fathers of the Church, and later formalized in social encyclicals and other magisterial texts.
Here’s a structured overview of key pre-1960 Church documents that explicitly emphasize love for and care of the poor, the vulnerable, and the working classes.
1. Rerum Novarum (1891) – Pope Leo XIII
Theme: The rights and duties of capital and labor.
Core message:
This encyclical is the foundation of modern Catholic social teaching. Leo XIII condemned both unrestrained capitalism and socialism, affirming the dignity of labor, the right to private property, and—centrally—the Church’s duty to protect and uplift the poor.
> “The rich must religiously refrain from cutting down the workman’s earnings, whether by force, by fraud, or by usurious dealing; and with all the greater reason because the poor man’s earnings are sacred.”
> — Rerum Novarum, §20
2. Quadragesimo Anno (1931) – Pope Pius XI
Theme: Reconstruction of the social order (issued 40 years after Rerum Novarum).
Core message:
Pius XI expanded Leo XIII’s teaching, calling for the reform of unjust economic systems and emphasizing solidarity with the poor. He highlighted subsidiarity—that social assistance should be provided at the lowest possible level while protecting the vulnerable.
> “Every effort must therefore be made that the poor and the workers be drawn closer to those who are rich.”
> — Quadragesimo Anno, §60
3. Mater et Magistra (1961) – Pope John XXIII
(Technically post-1960, but conceived in continuity with earlier documents.)
Theme: Christianity and social progress.
Core message:
John XXIII reaffirmed and updated Leo XIII and Pius XI, stressing that social development and economic justice are acts of love toward the poor.
> “The duty of every man is to consider his neighbor’s needs and rights as closely as his own.”
> — Mater et Magistra, §30
4. Summi Pontificatus (1939) – Pope Pius XII
Theme: The unity of human society.
Core message:
Issued at the start of World War II, this encyclical spoke of the moral obligation to uphold human dignity and aid those suffering from oppression, poverty, and war.
> “The nations of the earth are called to a higher justice and charity, without which peace and order cannot be restored.”
5. Deus Caritas Est (Patristic roots and continuity)
Although Deus Caritas Est itself is from 2005 (Benedict XVI), it explicitly cites the early Church practice — from Acts 2:44-45 and the writings of the Fathers — of communal sharing and love for the poor.
Before 1960, this tradition appeared in:
The Didache (1st–2nd century): “Do not turn away from one who is in need.”
St. John Chrysostom (4th century): “The property of the rich belongs to the poor.”
St. Ambrose (4th century): “You are not making a gift of your possessions to the poor person. You are handing over to him what is his.”
These ideas strongly influenced Leo XIII’s Rerum Novarum.
6. Mystici Corporis Christi (1943) – Pope Pius XII
Theme: The Church as the Mystical Body of Christ.
Core message:
By defining the Church as Christ’s living body, Pius XII grounded the duty of care for the poor in theology: to serve the poor is to serve Christ Himself.
> “Those who are most in need of comfort and assistance are the members who are the sick, the infirm, the poor.”
7. Missionary and charitable instructions
Several papal documents and Vatican directives prior to 1960 emphasized charity as an essential expression of faith:
Benedict XIV, Vix Pervenit (1745): Condemned usury and economic exploitation of the poor.
Leo XIII, Graves de Communi Re (1901): Called for Christian democracy rooted in charity and service to the poor.
Pius XII’s wartime addresses (1939–1958): Urged Catholics to rebuild society through compassion and justice.
Pre-Modern Teaching
Then chatGPT provided the following query:
Would you like me to include pre-modern sources (e.g., medieval papal bulls or conciliar decrees) that addressed poverty and charity — such as those from Gregory the Great, Innocent III, or the Council of Trent? They add important context to how the Church’s commitment to the poor developed before the industrial age.
My response:
Yes include pre-modern source
The Result
Excellent — that deepens the picture considerably.
When we widen the lens to include pre-modern (pre-19th-century) sources, we find that the care and love of the poor is not a late development but one of the most continuous and characteristic elements of Catholic doctrine.
Below is a chronological overview of key pre-1960 sources — now including patristic, medieval, and early-modern foundations — showing how the theme of charity toward the poor evolved from Gospel roots into formal Church teaching.
I. Scriptural and Patristic Roots (1st–6th centuries)
The biblical mandate — “Whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers of mine, you did for me” (Mt 25:40) — lies at the core of all later documents.
1. The Didache (c. A.D. 100)
> “Do not turn away from him who is in need; share all things with your brother.”
> Early Christian manual prescribing almsgiving as a moral duty.
2. The Apostolic Constitutions (4th cent.)
Regulations for bishops:
> “Let the bishop care for all, especially the poor, the widows, and the orphans.”
3. Church Fathers
St. Basil the Great, Homily to the Rich (4th cent.): “The bread you keep belongs to the hungry.”
St. John Chrysostom: “Not to share our wealth with the poor is to steal from them.”
St. Ambrose: Linked almsgiving with justice, not optional mercy.
St. Augustine: Developed the theology of the common use of goods (usus communis).
These Fathers shaped all subsequent papal and conciliar reflection on poverty and property.
🏛️ II. Early Medieval Teaching (6th–11th centuries)
4. Pope Gregory the Great, Regula Pastoralis (c. 590 A.D.)
Pastoral guide emphasizing bishops’ duty to use Church property for the poor:
> “Let him regard the riches of the Church as the patrimony of the poor.”
5. Monastic Rules
Rule of St. Benedict (6th cent.) ordered hospitality and almsgiving as expressions of humility and communal charity.
These rules institutionalized care of the poor in monasteries across Europe.
III. High and Late Middle Ages (12th–15th centuries)
6. Fourth Lateran Council (1215) – Innocent III
Mandated clerics to live modestly and use ecclesiastical revenues for the needy.
Canon 25: bishops must ensure support for the poor from cathedral funds.
7. Papal Bulls on Charity and the Poor
Innocent III, Cum inter nonnullos (1213): urged bishops to provide hospitals and hospices.
Gregory IX, Quo elongati (1230): confirmed Franciscan poverty ideal.
Nicholas III, Exiit qui seminat (1279): clarified that Franciscan renunciation served evangelical witness to the poor.
8. Scholastic Theology
St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II q. 32–66:
Almsgiving is a work of justice as well as mercy.
The poor have a right of necessity to what is superfluous to the rich.
These principles became the backbone of later social encyclicals.
IV. Early-Modern Era (16th–18th centuries)
9. Council of Trent (1545–1563)
Reaffirmed corporal works of mercy and required bishops to found seminaries and hospices; charity seen as essential to pastoral life.
Decree on Reformation (Sess. XXII, c. 1): Church revenues are to aid the poor before any luxury.
10. Papal and Post-Tridentine Actions
St. Pius V (1566–1572): enforced poor relief and hospital visitation by clergy.
Urban VIII, In eminenti (1622): supported missionary congregations providing education and care to the destitute.
Benedict XIV, Vix Pervenit (1745): condemned usury as exploitation of the poor — a decisive economic application of charity.
V. Nineteenth-Century Transition to Modern Social Teaching
11. Gregory XVI, Mirari Vos (1832) and Singulari Nos (1834)
While primarily doctrinal, they defended Christian charity as the moral counterweight to revolutionary violence.
12. Pius IX, Qui pluribus (1846) and Syllabus Errorum (1864)
Condemned materialism and indifferentism that ignored the poor; foreshadowed a social response later articulated by Leo XIII.
Progression of Church’s Teaching
As is usual chatGPT provided me with a next step:
Would you like me to present this as a **timeline or chart (2–3 pages)** showing how the Church’s teaching on the poor developed from *Acts of the Apostles* to *Mater et Magistra*? It would clearly trace the doctrinal continuity and main turning points.
The result
Comments
Post a Comment