+ JMJ Recently, I attended a meeting where we were asked to analyse a training scenario that required us to assess which of the characters acted honourably and to rank them. It was an interesting exercise and when discussing the actions of one character assaulting another, a colleague turned to me and said something to the effect that that character was the lowest ranking because "violence is never the answer". I thought that violence sometimes is necessary. Thus went the argument, until later the same colleague made a statement that contradicted their earlier stance. So, I have been wondering what is violence and is it morally permitted? Research and Discussion First, I went looking through my references and found the following in Moral Theology, by John A. McHugh and Charles J. Callan : 52. Violence, or coercion, is the use of force by an external agent to compel one to do what one does not want to do . Its effects on voluntariness are: (a) it cannot affect the inte...
+ JMJ Welcome to the New Year! I have no doubt that this year will hold more of the same confusion, conflict and wars - both Religious and Secular. So here's a list of links that attracted my attention. P^3 Popes Past Present and Future RORATE CÆLI: THE UPCOMING CONCLAVE: A Close Look at the College of Cardinals (Exclusive for Rorate) A Groundbreaking Interactive Website on the College of Cardinals Is Launched - Edward Pentin The Church and The Crisis US Commentator: Francis Has Completed His Mission – Gloria.tv Cardinal Defends Maya Eucharist: "Christ Did Not Celebrate the Latin Mass" – Gloria.tv Cardinal Burke: Situation Is 'Apocalyptic' – Gloria.tv 2024 State the Diocese - YouTube The SSPX Confirmed A Critical Rumor Is Actually True - YouTube Star launches podcast documentary on SSPX Resistance in West Cork | Southern Star Tradition in Action Bookstore - Catholic Books, Booklets, Cassettes, CDs DVDs Council Fathers on Ambiguity in Vatican...